pocket symphony

music, rant, video

i’ve not read much critical response to the new air album but i’m guessing a lot of it is negative or at least “blah” - i think there is something vaguely easy listening or ’smooth’ about air that leads to a lot of people dismissing their work as being ‘nice’ but not interesting. but then there’s statements like this - “With Pocket Symphony I’ve finally come to terms with the cold, hard fact that a return to the sounds of Moon Safari is unlikely. I’ve also stopped hating them for that.” what a toss. hey man, if you want moon safari again, go and buy yourself a second copy, voila. anyway, to my ears this record heads well and truly back into the territory explored by moon safari - the experimental peaks and gaps that littered 10000hz legend & talkie walkie have been smoothed over, there’s no “radio number one” or “run” on this album, nothing to jar the listener out of the smooth consistent flow of characteristic spaced-out ‘air-ness’. and there’s the same spacey atmospherics, kraut-rocky grooves & jazzy turns that characterise every air release (but especially their debut), here on pocket symphony sounding better than ever, better production, more varied and interesting instrumentation, and more focused songwriting. its a cruisy listen, & you can engage with it at any time or else just let it happen around you, just like moon safari. listen to pocket symphony opener “space maker” back to back with moon safari opener “la femme d’argent” - they are like the same person, la femme d’argent the naive unfocused younger version, space maker the wizened, focused, distilled older version. i mean thats whats kind of nice about moon safari, its naive, a band just starting out (i guess), but you can’t compare it to pocket symphony which is so fully realised and crystalline. AIR! you know, if you want to hear moon safari, get it off the shelf and put it on - that record has already been made, its not going to be made again. for the record i never really understood why people were so down on stereolab either, stereolab reviews always seemed obsessed with “yeah this stuff is ok, but why can’t they just make music like they did at the start?” - like they’d settled into some complacent rut because they actually started making interesting music. i went and bought old stereolab albums based on these reviews - they sucked! bring on “sound dust” & “margerine eclipse”!

incidentally, the new air track left bank really makes me think of nick drake’s river man, i don’t know why, i think its that i just love the sound of an acoustic guitar shifting from major chords to minor chords (and back again) in unexpected ways or ways that “shouldn’t work” but they do.

why are world cricket’s minnows (ireland, canada, united arab emirates, whatever) always called minnows?

Video: Air - Once Upon A Time

5 Responses

  1. Tim  •  April 22, 2007 @7:28 pm

    as a follow-up, metacritic provides a pretty quick and rough survey of the critical response to pocket symphony, which was definitely mostly of the blah variety. god bless review aggregators! now we can all rest easy knowing that this album is only 63% good! i can save my brain for more important things like watching big brother. link is here

    stylus: “This is the band’s most listless, amelodic effort to date.”
    prefix mag: “Symphony may have more of a cinematic steadiness and flow, but the absence of songs as hauntingly memorable as “Cherry Blossom Girl” or “Surfing on a Rocket” does not make for a better work.”
    popmatters: “Pocket Symphony is downright somnolent, like Talkie Walkie on Quaaludes. ”
    pitchfork: “Pocket Symphony winds up feeling strangely transient, accomplished and genuinely likeable but also forgettable.”

  2. Garvan  •  April 27, 2007 @12:21 pm

    Who’s the drummer in the vid?
    By the way - really enjoying the blog.
    Thanks.
    G

  3. Tim  •  April 27, 2007 @1:38 pm

    its tony allen. tony allen!

    and for the hell of it, here is yet one more misguided air review from drowned in sound: “Yet, with very little going on lyrically and the song swaying rather than jumping up and down, two minutes in I gave up, got the point and emotionally moved on. Therefore, I decided to go to YouTube and see if the video would help. Negative. Same shit, just with pictures. I love Air.. They can do better than this, though; ‘Once Upon A Time’ is too damn drum and bass-like in context.” wtf?

    online music reviewing is 2% passionate music-lovers and 98% dickwads

  4. Garvan  •  April 27, 2007 @2:22 pm

    Tim,
    My take is that album reviews are done by track down loaders. The body of work no longer stands up unless it’s a series of tracks that are all radio friendly. What ever happened to ‘Track 7″ - best song on an album? Side B, track 1.

  5. Danny J  •  May 30, 2007 @6:01 pm

    i’m really enjoying the new air album too.
    can people start listening with their ears?

Leave a Reply

Allowed tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>